Eggnog Jello Recipe

Eggnog jello

Eggnog jello

I know this may be coming to you late, but I had to squeeze this in, and share this recipe with you.  It is the second of my eggnog recipes for the holiday season.  I already shared with you the recipe for eggnog cheesecake bars, which is more for the cheesecake lover, rather than the eggnog lover, as the eggnog lent more of a smooth texture rather than flavor to the bars.  Well, this recipe is for the diehard eggnog lover, as the flavor of eggnog shines front and center.

This is my mom’s recipe that she has been making for many years, ever since I was in grade school.  I believe she got it from a friend.  My mom’s a jello lover, like me.  I know some people don’t like the chewy, sometimes rubbery texture of jello, especially finger jello, but the eggnog softens the texture of the gelatin, especially when you let the jello sit out at room temperature.

Believe it or not, the base of this recipe is lemon jello.  It turns out lemon jello blends very well with eggnog – so much so, you barely taste it, allowing the rich pure taste of eggnog to shine.


3 cups eggnog

1 cup water

4 packets (or 3 Tbsp + 1 tsp) of unflavored gelatin

3 oz lemon flavored Jello

1/2 cup sugar

1)  Stir unflavored gelatin, lemon Jello, and sugar together to combine in a medium saucepan.

2)  Add water to jello mixture.  Place saucepan over medium-low heat, stirring frequently, to dissolve sugar and gelatin.  Do not allow mixture to get too hot or come to a boil.  You want to heat it just enough for everything to dissolve, but not to curdle the eggnog, which you will add in the next step.

Mixing eggnog and lemon jello together

Mixing eggnog and lemon jello together

3)  Remove pan from heat.  Pour the eggnog in a steady stream into the jello mixture, stirring to mix.

4)  Pour jello into an 8-inch square baking pan.

5)  Refrigerate until set, about 2-3 hours.

Yield:  ~ 32 pieces, depending on how large you cut the pieces

Eggnog jello

Eggnog jello

Merry Christmas, everyone!  May your holiday be fun and relaxing, wherever and however you celebrate it :0)

What are some of your favorite eggnog recipes?  Please share in the comments.


About Serena Y Lee

Serena worked in the biotech industry for 18 years before leaving to pursue her life purpose – to live in freedom with creativity and simplicity. Her love for baking, creativity, and story-telling compelled her to start blogging to share her ideas with a wider audience.


2 Responses to Eggnog Jello Recipe

  1. Phyllis December 26, 2014 at 2:15 am #

    Looks delicious! Can’t wait to try it!! 🙂

    • Serena Y Lee December 28, 2014 at 4:44 am #

      Glad to hear you’re a fellow eggnog lover, Phyllis :0) Let me know if you try this recipe. It’s really quick and easy.

Leave a Reply

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers